CarMax, Inc.
Case Overview
60 Days Left to Seek Lead Plaintiff
| Lead Plaintiff Deadline: | Lead Plaintiff Deadline: 01/02/2026 |
| Status: | Status: Investigating |
| Company Name: | Company Name: CarMax, Inc. |
| Court: | Court: District of Maryland |
| Case Number: | Case Number: 1:25cv03602 |
| Class Period: | Class Period: 06/20/2025 - 09/24/2025 |
| Ticker: | Ticker: KMX |
| Related Attorneys: | Lead Attorneys: Thomas W. Elrod |
| Related Practices: | Related Practices: Securities |
The lawsuit alleges that Defendants recklessly overstated CarMax’s growth prospects when, in reality, its earlier growth in the 2026 fiscal year was a temporary benefit from customers buying cars due to speculation regarding tariffs.
On September 25, 2025, CarMax issued a press release entitled “CarMax Reports Second Quarter Fiscal Year 2026 Results” announcing, among other things, that a) retail unit sales decreased 5.4% and comparable store unit sales decreased 6.3%; wholesale units decreased 2.2% and b) net earnings per diluted share of $0.64 versus $0.85 a year ago. On the accompanying earnings call, representatives of the Company stated: “During our first quarter call, I mentioned that we saw an uptick in sales volume in March and April due to the tariff speculation. This impacted our performance in the second quarter in 2 ways. First, we ramped our inventory ahead of the second quarter to support this growth. Across the back half of May through the end of June, we saw about $1,000 in depreciation, which natively impacted our price competitiveness and our sales.” On this news, the price of CarMax shares declined by $11.50 per share, or approximately 20.07%, from $57.05 per share on September 24, 2025 to close at $45.60 on September 25, 2025.
On September 25, 2025, CarMax issued a press release entitled “CarMax Reports Second Quarter Fiscal Year 2026 Results” announcing, among other things, that a) retail unit sales decreased 5.4% and comparable store unit sales decreased 6.3%; wholesale units decreased 2.2% and b) net earnings per diluted share of $0.64 versus $0.85 a year ago. On the accompanying earnings call, representatives of the Company stated: “During our first quarter call, I mentioned that we saw an uptick in sales volume in March and April due to the tariff speculation. This impacted our performance in the second quarter in 2 ways. First, we ramped our inventory ahead of the second quarter to support this growth. Across the back half of May through the end of June, we saw about $1,000 in depreciation, which natively impacted our price competitiveness and our sales.” On this news, the price of CarMax shares declined by $11.50 per share, or approximately 20.07%, from $57.05 per share on September 24, 2025 to close at $45.60 on September 25, 2025.